Cesareans, asthma, and eczema (Part 1)

Is there a link between where and how your baby is born and her chances of developing asthma and atopic dermatitis (a.k.a. eczema) later in life?

Could be. Evidence is piling up that cesarean birth is associated with a moderately increased risk of these conditions. Recent studies have shown that cesarean birth is associated with the highest risk, followed by vaginal birth in the hospital. A vaginal birth at home seems to be the safest of all.

Heading for asthma?

It isn’t certain yet what the source of that link is (and I’ll talk about the difference between “association” and “causation” in a future post), but the signs are pointing to changes in the gut microbiota brought on by cesarean birth.

“Microbiota” is the name given to the collection of microorganisms that normally live in a given organ in the body. There’s a microbiota (that is, a group of germs) found in the mouth, for example, another that lives on the skin, and still another that populates the bowel. These bowel bacteria are usually picked up at birth – mainly from mother’s vagina and rectum in vaginal births, and from the skin and hospital environment in cesarean births.

Whatever the source, the bugs hike on down from mouth to bowel right after birth and set up shop. They do a lifetime of good things for us (they make vitamin K and do battle with bad germs, among many other things), and we feed* and care for them as our way of saying thanks. It’s a beneficial relationship that’s been with us for many millions of years.

Children born by cesarean section, though, generally have a higher count of “hospital bugs” in the bowel than those born vaginally. A particularly worrisome hospital bug is Clostridium difficile, a bacteria that is best known for causing serious diarrhea in the hospitalized elderly.

Here’s the cesarean-asthma theory in a nutshell: we evolved right along with the bowel germs we acquire during a vaginal birth, and when unusual germs like C. difficile show up instead, our immune system doesn’t like it. A low-grade, long-lasting bowel inflammation directed at these intruders can begin right after birth and last for years. To make an extremely long story short, that inflammation can make it easier to develop asthma, atopic dermatitis, and possibly other inflammatory diseases later on – even diabetes and obesity.

But hold on a moment before you head off to picket your local maternity ward. The cesarean-asthma link is not as clear-cut a case as it may seem…at least not yet. (More in Part 2).

(*Breast milk contains sugars that babies can’t digest – but that bowel bacteria eat right up. We love our bugs!)


Filed under Asthma, Cesareans, Natural childbirth, Science

7 responses to “Cesareans, asthma, and eczema (Part 1)

  1. Pingback: Vaginal Birth versus C-sections « drerindenil

  2. I just LOVE your blog, Dr. Sloan. I have been following it since it’s birth and really appreciate your work related to normalizing home birth. Your information is always of interest to me and it’s always easy for lay people to follow. Many many thanks!


    • Hi Carmen,
      Thanks for your kind words! I’m trying to keep the blog posts lay-reader-friendly (ie, not too med-wonky) and it’s a balancing act sometimes. Nice to know I’m succeeding.
      Take care,
      Mark Sloan


  3. Russell

    Dr sloan,

    I’m a cesarean born baby, I’m now in my mid thirty and I’m suffering from acute skin decease (acne conglobata). I’m looking for solution to my skin problem as I had tried almost all solutions available but it’s not really helping much. If you had any idea please share it with me. By the way the research is correct I do suffer from asthma too. Life is really complicate when born with cesarean physically and psychologically.



    • Hi Russell – acne conglobata is certainly a serious skin condition, and it’s a bit out of my specialty. Have you seen a dermatologist? Hopefully a good skin specialist can help you.
      Take care,
      Mark Sloan


  4. salome

    Dear doctor Sloan, I gave birth to my daughter through cesarean , she is 3 months old now. She never sleeps well at night , at times she is
    Breath ing faster and makes me worried. When she had running nose, her breathing is very fast. I’m always panic and prayed that she will be fine. We visited various local doctors but could not get any help, all they advise was to keep the baby warm all the time. Please I need your help ,,,,,,.


    • Hi Salome – It wouldn’t be appropriate for me to give you advice without being able to see your daughter. I will say though that if her breathing doesn’t interfere with feeding, then it’s very unlikely that there’s anything serious going on. I hope you can find a physician who will be able to answer all your concerns. All best – Mark Sloan


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s